Total Weight:
50 lbs (22.67 kg)
Battery Weight:
7.5 lbs (3.4 kg)
Motor Weight:
7.6 lbs (3.44 kg)
Frame Material:
ALUXX SL-Grade Aluminum
Frame Sizes:
17 in (43.18 cm)19 in (48.26 cm)21 in (53.34 cm)23 in (58.42 cm)Geometry Measurements:
Large: 21" Seat Tube, 22" Reach, 31" Stand Over Height, 73" Length
Frame Types:
High-Step
Frame Colors:
Charcoal Fighter Grey
Frame Fork Details:
Rigid ALUXX SL-Grade Aluminum, OverDrive, 9 mm Skewer with Bolts
Frame Rear Details:
9 mm Skewer with Bolts
Attachment Points:
Fender Bosses, Rear Rack Bosses, Bottle Cage Bosses
Gearing Details:
20
Speed 2x10 Shimano Deore Shadow Rear Derailleur 11-36T, Shimano Deore Front Derailleur 36/48TShifter Details:
Shimano Deore Triggers on Left and Right
Cranks:
Custom Forged, 170 mm Length
Pedals:
Alloy Platform Cage
Headset:
Tapered 1-1/8" to 1-1/2"
Stem:
Alloy, 100 mm Length, 8° Angle, Three 5 mm Stacks, One 10 mm Stack
Handlebar:
Alloy Low-Rise, 31.8 Clamp Diameter, 29" Width
Brake Details:
Shimano M315 Hydraulic Disc with 180 mm Front Rotor 160 mm Rear Rotor, Shimano M315 Levers with Adjustable Reach
Grips:
Giant, Flat Rubber, Locking
Saddle:
Giant Contact Upright
Seat Post:
Alloy
Seat Post Length:
300 mm
Seat Post Diameter:
30.9 mm
Rims:
Giant Alloy, Double Wall, 32 Hole, Reinforcement Eyelets
Spokes:
Stainless Steel, 14G Front, 13G Rear, Black with Nipples
Tire Brand:
Schwalbe Big Ben, 27.5" x 2.0"
Wheel Sizes:
27.5 in (69.85cm)Tire Details:
Reflective Sidewall Stripe, Puncture Protection
Tube Details:
Schrader
Accessories:
Giant Composite Plastic Fenders, Rear Pannier Rack, Integrated AXA Blueline30 LED Headlight, Integrated Spanninga Vena LED Rear Light, Ursus Adjustable Length Kickstand
Other:
Locking Removable Battery Pack, 1.8 lb 3 Amp Charger
Roman
8 years agoHey Court, thanks for the review, this is a bike I’ve been considering for a while. Can you talk about the sizing? What size did you test and what size do you usually ride? I’ve cross shopped this with the Specialized Turbo X, which do you think gets the nod for a 22 mile roundtrip commute with a bit of gravel?
ReplyCourt Rye
8 years agoHi Roman! I believe I was on the larger frame size but cannot say for sure. Trevor is a taller guy and I remember the bike feeling large, it’s great to visit a dealer and try them out if you can. I believe Giant is requiring their dealers to bring a few ebikes into their shops. I love the efficiency of the Giant mid-drive and how beautiful it looks but the Turbo X suspension fork is a big deal for me given the speed produced. I have sensitive wrists, arms, shoulders, neck and back. For this reason, I usually only buy full suspension ebikes now so I’m a bit extreme ;)
Honestly, this is a great product at a great price. I’m being honest about my appreciation of suspension but that’s just me. Trevor seemed very happy with this bike for himself and I enjoyed test riding it!
ReplyShaggy
8 years agoNice to see one of the big 3 (Trek, Specialized, Giant) make an ebike. Should help the consumer. Court, I am wondering if the Yamaha cuts out early due to the size of the front chainring or the software being set to stop assisting once the sensors indicate a certain pedal crank rpm? Thx.
ReplyCourt Rye
8 years agoHi Shaggy! I think it’s just designed with a different RPM range… like it won’t go any faster up to a certain point whereas Bosch will. Bosch also stops but I find the bit of extra RPM at the higher end to be more comfortable and supportive of my ride style. I have hurt knees and the higher RPM requires less pressure on non-electric bikes so that’s how I prefer to ride now. It’s not a deal killer, I know my feedback on this characteristic has rubbed some people the wrong way and they get defensive. To me it’s just a fact and I’m trying to be open about it and show it on video. If you get onto one of these at a dealer and compare it to Bosch or Brose back to back and emphasize fast pedaling while in higher gears going for the top speed… I think you’ll see what I mean. I hope this helps!
ReplyCarter
8 years agoThis is very helpful. Your review just pushed the Quick-e (terrible name) into my top 3 ebikes to consider, along with the new Vado when it comes out and the Trek Super Commuter+ if I win the lottery (ha). Obviously I’m one of those who prioritizes name brand and dealer support– Giant’s 2 year warranty is a big plus as well.
Court, I have a suggestion for your reviews. The main reason I’m looking at buying an ebike is, at 55 and 185 lbs, I struggle too much getting up the hills around Seattle on my 20-50 mile fun rides. The steeper climbs are really the only times I need assist (tho I don’t pretend I won’t use it at other times.) I suspect I’m not the only prospective ebike buyer in this position. Towards that end, it’d be super helpful if you were able to speak to the relative performance of the bikes you review in providing assist on longer and steeper climbs. Of course I understand that may not be possible if you’re testing the bike in a flat region- still.
I rode my cousin’s Stromer in the San Francisco hills last summer and marveled at how I flew up the (steep!) hills, but was disappointed when the base model Specialized Turbo I test rode (twice) failed to provide the same amount of assist. If you were able to try out your review bikes on hills where possible and give some feedback as to how they performed I could really use that information. Thanks so much!
ReplyCourt Rye
8 years agoGood suggestion Carter, I do seek out hills and completely see how it helps people like you to get an understanding and see performance. I’m relatively light weight and active so even that can be misleading I suppose. Regarding the Quick-E+, I’d say it is a very capable climber given the mid-motor and high torque (80 Nm) that Yamaha delivers. I’d love to hear your thoughts on how it performs vs. a Stromer but would compare it favorably based on my own experiences. It’s different, being center-driven, but better if you shift accordingly… you don’t have to push as hard as with the newer Stromer ST1 X.
ReplyNicholas
7 years agoHi Carter – I’m also in Seattle, I currently commute from West Seattle to SLU most days on an old fashioned SOMA doublecross. My top three are similar – Trek Supercommuter 8+, The Giant Quick-e, and I’ve been looking at the Specialized. The Quick-e is in the lead because for the price I can upgrade to the suspension post with a Brooks saddle and clip-in pedals and still be well below the Trek. I climb 550ft on the way home, and that’s the big impetus for going electric. Just gets exhausting after a long week or a 10 hour day. Did you pull the trigger? What did you choose?
ReplyBrian
8 years agoI noticed that this US version speed pedelec comes with a relatively weak Axa Blueline 30 headlight…the European s-pedelec versions have the Supernova m-99, even the Quick-e+ 25 comes with the Axa Blueline 50 in the European models. I would think that a stronger light should be a safety feature for any s-pedelec. Any thoughts on this?
ReplyCourt Rye
8 years agoInteresting, thanks for noticing and sharing this detail Brian. I guess it’s a bummer that the US got downgraded… unless ours is also less expensive? We have a lot of electric bikes out here that bend the rules with speed and power which don’t have ANY lights. I don’t know enough about the situation to make a judgment call but I’m inclined to trust that Giant is making decent decisions? I felt that the rest of the product was well thought-out?
ReplyEmerson Moncure
8 years agoHey Court, I just discovered electricbikereview.website and I love it! The reviews on this channel are informed, thorough and extremely well communicated. Currently I commute to work on a Giant brand Seek 3 (non-electric) I bought back in 2012 for $700. Though I really like my bike, I’ve been feeling like its time for an upgrade. However, I never would have considered an e-bike (let alone a $3000 e-bike) until I watched the EBR review of the Giant Quick-E! To be honest, I’m not a particularly knowledgeable consumer when it comes to bikes, and I rely heavily on an informed sales person to help me find the right fit. The danger there is, I don’t always get an informed sales person! However after watching a number of EBR reviews I have a new understanding of the value of electric bikes, and particularly the value of specific products being offered! Considering my needs and compared to other e-bikes of this quality, $3000 really seems a good price vs. value for the Giant Quick E. It even has the same graphite grey/black color scheme as my old Seek 3. I’m sold! This newly informed rider thanks you for your top quality reviews!
ReplyCourt Rye
8 years agoHey Emerson! You totally made my day, thanks for sharing a bit about yourself and what it’s like to be a consumer trying to navigate the space. I’m glad the site has helped you, that’s my goal! And, feel free to share or connect further in the forums. I do my best as an information source but have limited experience post-purchase. I feel like individuals connecting directly is an authentic way to identify issues, fixes, and best uses. Have a great time out there and thanks again!
ReplyRandy Emer
8 years agoHey Court, I love watching your reviews, they’re incredibly helpful and informative. I’m a very recreational rider in the market for an e-bike. I seem to have narrowed the choice down to two: the Giant Quick-E above, and the Trek Dual Sport +. They seem very similar. What are your thoughts? You are providing a tremendous service with your enthusiastic reviews!!!
ReplyCourt Rye
8 years agoHi Randy! Great bikes… both companies are large and trustworthy but I prefer the Giant in this case because it has a streamlined battery, integrated lights, fenders and a basic rack. I guess it depends on the sort of rides you want to take, but I appreciate the added utility. Both drive systems are good and the 2017 Shimano batteries can be charged on-bike just like the Giant Quick-E+ Yamaha battery. I hope this helps! Would love to hear what you decide on and how it works for you. Feel free to poke around the forums too and ask for feedback from actual owners :)
ReplyCristian
8 years agoHi, I’m interested in this bike but I read about the “cons” that both wheels are secured. I’m not from the US but I’ll be there in a couple of weeks, I would like to dismantle to transport by flight…. Would be easier for me to transport? Thanks!
ReplyCourt Rye
8 years agoHi Cristian! First off, you might have to ship the battery separately from the bike because most commercial airlines do not allow you to bring large Lithium-ion batteries onboard. They won’t even let you check them… consider reaching out to a hazmat certified shipper like Propel Bikes in New York or ask your dealer. Second, it’s pretty easy to use a basic set of tools to get the wheels off of this bike. You might want to purchase a large padded bike box because checking these things could end up damaging them. This is just the start but I hope it helps you to reconsider the shipping plan… there’s a lot more than just taking the wheels off to consider :)
ReplySamuel
7 years agoHi Court! Thank you for your excellent reviews, they will help me a lot in choosing an E-bike, bet on the future and leave the car aside.
Do you have something to say about the quality of the battery? I think that most bicycle brands use electrical components from manufacturers that have the experience and the technology to produce motors, controls and batteries. So I wonder how good quality is a battery from Giant and its lifespan.
I’m thinking about buying an E-bike for my daily commuting (which is 20 km) and stop using the car, but batteries are a big concern to me: how long they last, what to do when a battery has reached maximum cycle capacity (where to recycle?) and how long manufacturers will support an old model with replacement batteries. Would you consider this before choosing an e-bike?
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoHi Samuel! Batteries are one of the most sensitive and expensive parts of electric bikes but if you get one that’s relatively new and provided by a large, trusted manufacturer like Giant, Specialized, Trek or any Bosch powered product, I think you’re doing great. These companies tend to cost a little more but have long-term customer service and replacement options. Most batteries, if not dropped and stored in cool dry locations and kept at ~80% for long term storage, should last for several years and maybe longer :)
ReplyChuck
7 years agoHi Court,
Yet another excellent review from you! Thanks very much for that. One of those Giant Quick-e+ pluses passed through the bike shop I work at last week and unfortunately I was far too busy to give it a proper look-over so I have a few questions I hope you can answer. Giant didn’t cover enough in the specs on their site, hence me asking you. Beyond that, I have a few words. I’ve got to say, that bike really caught my eye. It looks like a really stout build and it’s just a good looking bike overall from the few minutes I had with it.
Those first two questions may seem a bit nerdy but I’m going to want to tweak that bike some. Not much, just some. It seems just about perfect as-is. Oh and speaking of bike tweaks you often mention seatposts like the Cane Creek Thudbuster. I’d like to point out another one I think is worth considering. The Niner RDO carbon seatpost. It’s not going to have anywhere near as much give as a Thudbuster but it is intentionally built with some compliance and dampening in mind. I was pretty skeptical about the claim but after trying one I now run them on a couple of my bikes and they do make a very noticeable difference at far less weight and with a clean look. Other people who have ridden my bikes have remarked on how good they feel without me saying a word about them. They are a bit pricey but definitely worth it in my opinion. The setback model gives even a little more comfort if that’s something someone can properly fit on their bike.
I really like that the Quick-e comes out of the box with plump 650B wheels vs. 700c. 700c has its merits (I love my gravel bike!) but 650B I think is just best all around for something utilitarian like that bike. Far more stout and comfortable. Not only that but I think 650B wheels are a better choice than 700c for a class 3 ebike. For those not familiar with the terrifyingly sketchy fun of going 40+ mph on skinny little 23c tires (or 30+ on fat gravel bike tires) those 650B fatties will go a long way in adding safety and confidence in the 20-30MPH range. Also, I know those WTB tires the owner in the video upgraded to and they are very smooth and efficient. Probably a great upgrade. That’s not to say that the stock Schwalbe Big Bens are not good. They too are an excellent tire.
That pannier rack, the overall clean lines of the bike along with the highly functional lighting and clean, simple dashboard grabbed my attention right away as I was walking by it at my shop last week and I had to take a second look and prod n’ poke the bike for a couple of minutes. I think the price is perfect too. I’m thinking about one quite seriously. The days I don’t feel like commuting by bike I ride my motorcycle and I’d like to get away from that. For those days that I don’t want to deal with changing out of my kit, getting grimy or am just feeling lazy and just want to throw my leg over a bike and go without doing anything special then pedaling a little less hard seems to fit the bill. I’ve borrowed a few ebikes from my shop to try them out for commuting and I get it now. I think motos trump a car most of the time for personal transport here in SoCal. But I’m 70/30 bike/moto in my commuting habits now and the moto is getting a bit tedious. For my short travels I do most of the time I’d rather be on a bike. My family has been car-light for a few years now and I’m thinking something like that bike may just scratch my itch and keep me car-light for a few more years.
Thanks for all of your hard work on these great reviews!
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoHi Chuck! Happy to help with the specs… It does have a tapered head tube and no, there are not motor inhibitors built in. Most of the new advanced mid-drive ebikes do not use cutoff switches or have throttles, I guess they are quick enough that the inhibitor is not needed? Unfortunately, I cannot answer the last question about chainring but my guess is that it does use a standard BCD.
Good call on the carbon seat post, have you seen the one that Specialized made? Used to be called the “Cobl Gobl-R” but the official name is now CB-R :)
ReplyChuck
7 years agoOh yeah, I forgot about that one from Specialized! Looks like another good choice. It’s pretty interesting some of the carbon layups manufactures are trying these days and how they can control stuff like compliance and direction of flex. Much more advanced (and durable) than the old days of carbon.
Mike
7 years agoHey Court! Your website is awesome. I am a first time buyer and this is by far the best source I have found. A quick question, do you know (or know how I can determine) when the 2018 Quick-e+ will come out? I went to a local dealer and he seemed to think it will be the next few weeks. Thank you!
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoWow, that sounds crazy soon? I guess the 2017 model has been around for a while now but I feel like we are mid-season. Sometimes they get demo models for press events and shows like Eurobike and Interbike (many of their bikes are designed for a European audience and then brought to the US). I’ll ask my contacts at Giant and see if we get anything… Glad you like the site Mike!
ReplyMike
7 years agoGreat, thank you. I searched online and could not find any information about the expected release date.
giantbike
7 years agoCourt, if difference in price was not a factor, would you go with the Lacuba evo 45 or the Giant for a 30 mile total commute?
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoHmm… I’d probably go with the Lacuba EVO E45 in mid-step with that suspension fork. I care a lot about comfort and could see myself commuting with these bikes. Even though the Giant Quick-E+ looks nicer to me, the Bulls offers similar utility (lights, fenders) and even has that adjustable bar and ergo grips. One of the other factors I consider is motor type and I prefer the Brose drive vs. the older Yamaha with limited RPM because I like to spin fast. I really like the pricepoint and integrated look of the Giant but my priority is comfort, especially at higher speeds. One other factor might be if there was a dealer nearby, you could get the Giant, swap in a suspension fork, outfit it with nice accessories and maybe a riser stem or swept back bar and ergo grips for similar price as the Bulls. There are many ways to go with this. Hope my thoughts help you decide :)
Replygiantbike
7 years agoYeah, the huge 203mm brakes on the e45 and the 650w battery are nice adds too. I agree the Giant looks great. I’m a big fan of the Brose motor and have many hours on one, but I have limited experience with the Yamaha. It’s nice to see so much competition brewing in the motor department. It would be great if someone could come up with some common metrics on how to compare motors based on torque and efficiency as it gets quickly complicated when you add speed and cadence to the equation. Seems like the only way to get a feel is to ride the bike. It’s great to see so many class 3’s coming out, I agree with your opinion that class 3s are approaching the ability to replace a car, at least for commuting.
Robert Foote
7 years agoThe lack of a proper rear rack (one that extends above the fender and readily allows for a rear bag or purse to be carried without panniers) is absurd. It is sad that some Giant marketing weasel chose form over function on an accessory that will be used quite often. Another huge oversight is the lack of a guard for the large chain-ring. People using this bike are very likely to be wearing pants and should not have to put on a pants clip. These two items represent low-hanging fruit – how they could be overlooked is something that Giant should be very much ashamed of. One can only wonder if they can’t get the simple shit right, what about the really difficult stuff???
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoI see where you’re coming from but feel that the minimalist pannier arms and multi-chainring setup make sense here. It can get cluttered and rattly with a big plastic chain cover that’s large enough to cover a front derailleur, and if they had a platform rack in the rear the bike just wouldn’t look as sleek and would definitely weigh more (maybe half a pound?) I see why they chose these things, there are definitely other e-bikes out there which do have full sized racks and protected chains, it seems like they did choose form over a bit of function, but it’s not as extreme as it could have been with no support arms or a single chainring and no cover.
ReplyRobert Foote
7 years agoThank you for taking the time to respond, though I must respectfully disagree on one point. I do not believe it is even possible to purchase a bicycle rack that can only accommodate panniers. There is a good reason for this. The additional weight to provide the standard rectangular upper platform is insignificant (not even close to half a pound). If the utility of a proper rack upper platform justifies the additional weight on a typical 27 lb touring bike, it certainly is not a factor on a 50 lb e-bike. I simply find it annoying that after spending $3K on an e-bike, I would need to spend another $100 or more for panniers so that my wife can carry her purse. Panniers would also weigh far more than the additional aluminum tubing. Regarding my other complaint, I was unclear as to my suggested modification. I have no problem with the double chain-rings, and certainly wasn’t lobbying for a fully enclosed chain. What I was referring to is a bolt-on, aluminum alloy (not plastic) chain-ring guard. These guards are very light, robust, and practical. They have been used on single, double and triple chain-ring cranksets for decades.
Rob Withey
7 years agoI’m in Canada and Giant have a new rack coming with a flat top for carrying things and pannier mounting. Hope to have mine soon.
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoVery cool, thanks for the update Rob! We’d love to hear how it works out for you. Feel free to share even more details and pictures in the Giant Ebike Forums if you’d like.
Tim
7 years agoI was just checking out the Quick E at the local bike shop and thought the same thing about that rack. That was a big concern with me for commuting. I was shocked they didn’t have a proper rear rack on there. I like to haul a lot of gear back there. As soon as the weather improves I intend to take it for a test ride.
Replycourt
7 years agoCool, I’d love to hear your thoughts on the bike once you take a test ride Tim, good luck!
David
7 years agoJust wanted to say thanks for your great reviews. Until about a week ago I hadn’t given electric bikes a second thought. Heard a passing reference on a radio station about a week ago and thought I’d take a quick look one after noon while cruising internet. I was blown away by the selection, capabilities and technology involved. I have since ordered a Giant Quick E+, was waffling between it and the IZIP Dash, but your reviews tipped me toward the Giant. Looking forward to my first commute, without burning fuel and getting some exercise and especially help at the end of the day on those hills. One quick question can you recommend a set of panniers that would fit this type of rack, encorporating room for labtop, change of cloths/lunch? Thanks again David.
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoHi David! Welcome to the ebike community :D these things are a blast and yes… there are so many to choose from now. I think you made a great choice with the Giant Quick-E+ and am assuming you found a local dealer to help get fitted and stuff? They might have some panniers or bag options for you to check out, but I like the clip-on style like this which are easy to take off and bring inside. Please note that I have not tested that specific bag and cannot confirm if it would fit for you… but Amazon has a good return policy and this might just get you thinking about options. Ortleib has some good stuff but they are more expensive usually. When using panniers, I often bring my charger and work stuff but may also wear a backpack to keep my laptop extra safe when commuting. There are lots of options and people in the forums might also have some ideas. I created this article about other good accessories to consider for ebikes that might get your gears turning ;)
ReplyAlasdair
7 years agoThanks for the great reviews Court. I’ve had one of these for 4 months now and it’s been ideal for my 20 mile each way commute. The only thing lacking is the ability to mount a larger chainring (only has clearance for 48t which is too small), and the lighting which is too dim for my liking.
Do you know what lighting upgrade options are? I cant find the output voltage for the light. Id love to add something like the Supernova m99 pro.Thanks, Alasdair
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoHi Alasdair! Great insights there, thanks for sharing your feedback about the limited chainring clearance. Those are the types of things I am learning about and trying to share more but it’s wonderful to get comments like yours, especially since you have been riding now for four months. It sounds like you’re enjoying the bike, I do believe that the Supernova M99 Pro could be added but it might take a special shop to order and then install. I have seen this done by the folks at OHM on their Sport model (you can see it on Michael’s bike in the video review on this page).
Personally, I have found that the Cygolite rechargeable lights work well and provide flashing, bright, and dim modes. They offer combo packs like this or you can just get a bright headlight on its own. They are less convenient and secure than an integrated light (so more time turning on/off and removing them when parking in public). They offer some very bright models like this with 1,100 lumens! and there are many others on Amazon to explore, I’d love to hear back what you decide to do.
ReplyAlasdair
7 years agoCourt – good tip but I already have a range or battery lights from Exposure and am looking for similar power but the simplicity of running it off the battery like the one installed. I heard back from AXA who make the OEM light and they do a bigger 50LUX model that runs off 6v (which I assume is the output). I’ll order it and swap out as its only $40.
I have quite a bit of experience with this bike now having ridden around 4000 miles and done a few upgrades/experiments so please anyone reach out if they have any questions. I know I really could have dome with this resource when I was shopping to understand the rack situation as well as a few others.
Court keep up the great work – I can see this as the future of daily transportations and your efforts are very instrumental to us getting there!
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoThat’s awesome Alasdair! How did you find out who to reach at AXA? The price is great… I’d love to see the finished product and maybe get some tips from you in the Giant forums as I am sure there are others out there who would love to do the same thing.
So glad to hear that EBR helped and appreciate your willingness to pay it forward by answering questions from anyone else about the bike. I agree that this technology is transformative and empowering, so glad to be part of sharing it with the world :)
ReplyAndrew
7 years agoHi Alasdair – I actually own the bike that is in this review! Trevor hooked me up with a great price and am taking it in for a tune up this week. I have similar issues with the lights – I run a separate Knog Blinder in the rear at night for safety, but would for sure be interested in a brighter light setup. If you can link out to your solution that’d be awesome. I will do some research in the meantime. I really like/prefer having lights running off my battery so any aftermarket solutions for the head & taillights would be awesome.
I’d also echo the sentiments from others – the biggest gripe I have about this bike is how I spend almost ALL of my time in the top two gears. It’s not a deal breaker, but it just makes the other front chainring feel completely useless and unnecessary. Even on a big(ger) climb I’m still in the middle-top gears overall, so it is a little disheartening to learn that can’t be changed.
The pannier/rack thing also bothers me, as I have two rack trunk/dual pannier bags that can’t fit on this bike due to the lack of a flat platform. I knew that when I purchased the bike, so now I’m looking into basket options. I really like the look of the Blackburn Local basket, but I feel like if mounted on the front it would block my headlight, and if mounted on the back it wouldn’t clear the embedded pannier rack/bars. Any tips or solutions for a porter-style basket?
Thanks all!
ReplyAlasdair
7 years agoHey Andrew, You bike was the reason I got mine then – especially with the WTB tires and your commute sounds just like mine (20 miles each way in LA right?). I’ve been fine so far with the rack. These Brooks Suffolk Panniers work great and are adjustable enough. I have mine loaded up with around 25lb of gear each day an they’re so low down I barely notice them.
Court – I just used the contact link on the AXA web page, someone responded within a day or two. Still struggling to find out what the output for the light is but this should work wither way. I’ll have it on the bike within a week, great as the light is fading earlier each day.
As Court suggests I’ll take this to the correct forum and post there.
Rob Withey
7 years agoSee my above comment. There is a new rack coming that will take panniers.
Steve
7 years agoHi Court – Great bike review! I have been looking at this bike for mile 20 mile each-way commute and I think it fits the bill pretty well. Do you know what the differences are between the 2017 and 2018 models?
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoHi Steve! I haven’t had an opportunity to look closely at the 2018 yet but I hope to review it later this year or early next. Maybe you could ask in the EBR Giant Forums or do a comparison with the official spec on the Giant website? If you discover anything, please share back here, I’d love to know but am just busy traveling right now so cannot dig in myself.
ReplyWeston
7 years agoIs this range accurate? It seems way too high at 50 miles minimum and 100 miles maximum range on a charge. That seems absurd. Anybody have any feedback on that?
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoHi Weston! I agree, and I don’t rememeber exactly how I came up with that estimate. It might have been suggested by Giant but the Yamaha system is indeed efficient and this bike doesn’t have knobby tires or suspension so it’s also going to coast well. My guess would be 35+ minimum on the highest level of assist going fast (because 20+ mph speeds do sap the battery quicker based on air resistance). Thank you for chiming in and I apologize that the stats I got seem misleading.
ReplyNate
7 years agoRange is definitely not accurate (the only way you’re getting 100 miles on a charge is by coasting downhill in Eco mode most of the way). I’ve had this bike since August and have been commuting with it about half the time. Since I work out of two different offices, my commutes are either 2.5 miles or 5.5 miles and mostly flat with one good-sized hill on each route (I’m in Mountain View, CA and my route takes me over 85 or the 101). I mostly leave it in the normal setting, with the occasional switch to Eco mode if I’m trying to eke out a few more miles or sometimes up it to Power if I’m in a hurry on a hill or if I know I’m going to need to charge when I get home so I might as well use up some juice. Every time I take the battery off to charge, I first snap a picture showing the miles since I last charged and the % of battery remaining. Then I calculate the mileage capacity by taking (miles traveled)/(1 – % remaining). Over the course of ~520 miles and 15 charges, I’ve been getting a mean 41.4 miles per charge. Max was 45.6 miles, min was 36.6 miles.
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoThis is awesome feedback Nate, thank you so much for sharing your personal experience with the bike. I used to live in Mountain View and miss it, beautiful place! You sound like a smart person, someone who is detail oriented. I hope the bike holds up well for you and that this comment provides a more accurate perspective to other potential customers. Thank you.
Rob
7 years agoI’m heading out west and realize that at close to 70 years of age – I can’t get up those multiple mile climbs anymore without a bit of assistance – I need and electric bike.
I visited with Chris over at Propel Bikes in Brooklyn – great shop, lots of e-bike inventory; and Chris like you Court, is very knowledgeable about e-Bikes.
So I narrowed down the field to the Giant Quick E+ and the Specialized Vado 3.0. Truth be told I like the high speed of the Giant but liked the feel of the Vado 3.0.
My biggest concern is which bike will hold up better and require the least amount of maintenance – getting spare parts and having the bike serviced quickly is important – I don’t want to be waiting for weeks to have parts delivered. Your thoughts, please!
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoGreat question Rob, I think you’re in good hands with Chris at Propel… I would defer to him, since you have spent more time together. Both of these are leading brands, it may come down to price, style, or what he has to say off record about what has held up best. I only get the brand new bikes and they all seem to work… but Chris would have deeper knowledge since he actually sells and services them. Perhaps he would even recommend some other brand you haven’t tried yet, like Kalkhoff or Focus with Bosch drive systems for a similar price (he mostly carries Bosch because they have been super reliable for him).
ReplyGary Peacock
7 years agoI’ve spent a lot of time looking at your reviews and REALLY appreciate all the info! I’m in the Adirondack Mountains and plan on doing some hilly rides (I live on top of a 2+ mile hill with a 1,000 ft climb at the end of my ride) so I want a bike that will help me get home! I also plan on riding some dirt roads (logging roads), but not really Mtn bike riding. The Giant Quick E+ looks like the bike for me, but I’m a bit confused by the “Commuter” class. Most of the discussion is about commuting, but I’m not riding to work… just riding mostly on quiet country back roads. Should I be looking elsewhere for my needs? 80%-90% of my riding will be on pavement, but want the ability to ride occasionally on rougher dirt roads without hurting the bike. Thoughts? Also, is it possible to swap out the handle bar grips for the ergo type grips found on the Trek XM-700? Thanks so much for any suggestions!
ReplyCourt Rye
7 years agoHi Gary! Yes, grips are generally very easy and inexpensive to swap out. There are many choices at local shops and online, these Ergon GP1 grips are similar to the ones you saw on the Trek XM7000… but there are also ones like this with bar-ends for a different hand position, to reduce fatigue on longer rides. You could probably also purchase the exact same Bontrager grips from a Trek dealer if you like that red accent or the ribbed style. It appears that they might only have a black/grey combo being sold aftermarket right now.
Regarding your question about ride style… I tend to classify electric bikes based on their full potential here, and see commuter as an upgrade from mere neighborhood and urban riding. The commuter classification denotes fenders, lights, and a rear rack. The tires on the Giant Quick-E+ are also quite good, with reflective sidewalls and puncture protection. Yes, this ebike could definitely handle some light gravel streets, but it might not be very comfortable. It doesn’t have a suspension fork and the geometry is more sporty and active. You probably won’t damage the bike, the tubular fenders look pretty tough as well, but you might get a sore back, neck, shoulders, wrists, etc. and if you do a lot of trail riding, a ShockStop stem and 30.9 mm suspension seat post like this could reduce body fatigue and impact. I hope this helps! Giant seems to make good bicycle products and the Yamaha drive system here is one that I trust :)
Replymarcel
6 years agoHello, is there someone out there who has changed the cogwheel / gear / sprocket?I have this bike without a speed limitation, but I make a lot of rotations (have to pedal very fast). With changing the cogwheel / gear / sprocket, maybe I can make less rotations but keeping the same speed… I think I can’t change anything in the back but only the cogwheel / gear / sprocket in the front. I also had some errors, falling out of the power and sometimes an A1 warning… but the last weeks no problems at all. grt marcel
Replysteve
6 years agoI test rode this and I’m pretty surprised by the mostly positive review:
I can’t argue with all the praise of the mechanics and power, which seems to be where all the focus of the review is. It’s pretty zippy, but what’s the point if the rest of it’s so poorly designed?
Replycourt
6 years agoGreat feedback, Steve. Thanks for taking the time to share your perspectives. Hope you’re able to test some other models and find one that feels comfortable as well as powerful ;)
ReplyJon
6 years agoI bought my quick-e for a commute of 28 miles. No matter how I toggle the assist modes, I’m averaging only 27/28 miles on a charge. I’ve pedaled the last few miles with no charge left a few times. With an on board computer that lists minimum range of 42 miles on sport + mode, and the fact that I’m running it on this mode 50% of the time, I should be getting over 50 on a charge. Is GIANT falsely advertising the range or do I have a warranty issue?
ReplyCourt
6 years agoHmm, thanks for the feedback Jon! I cannot say for sure, but perhaps the combination of faster riding, the terrain and conditions, and your weight are contributing to the lower range? Yamaha built their drive system, and they tend to be very reliable and accurate, but there are many factors outside of their control that can either raise or lower range. This sounds like a good question for your dealer. Maybe they could check the system to see if the battery is lower than expected or if there are other ways to improve range? Wish I could help more :/
ReplyScott
6 years agoI’m thinking of buying one of these used and I am a bit concerned by the lack of a fork suspension. Would going to bigger tires, say 27.5 x 2.35 that can run at lower pressures help to smooth out the ride adequately?
What about mounting an after market suspended fork? I see a lot of these on various websites for about $100 – $50. Is this a fairly straight swap out? Thanks for your help – I really do appreciate the high quality reporting on your site.
ReplyCourt
6 years agoHi Scott, the tires on this ebike are already a bit wider and higher volume than average, I think you could ride with them a bit lower PSI for comfort… and maybe add a seat post suspension. The tapered head tube would fit a range of aftermarket suspension, so that’s a good thing to consider, but it might be nicer looking and cost similar to just find an ebike that already has a suspension fork. There are many to choose from now… but on the other hand, it’s cool to customize a bike! I’d love to hear what you end up doing, or even see pictures in the Giant forum :)
ReplyAimee Pelletier
6 years agoHi Court, I am trying to decide between a few different mid-drive set-ups. I am 5′ 7″ and 165 lbs. I seem to fit M or 50cm frames well. My primary use for the ebike will be commuting 2-3 times per week 32km round trip on paved bicycle rail-to-trail (so minimal hills) and for around Greater Victoria, BC, so I want it to be set up with fenders and pannier racks. Integrated lights would be nice, but I imagine I will have to add on a stronger front light for commuting on bike pathways at night. I want the ebike to feel like a regular bike (hence the mid-drive) and I want to get lots of exercise.
My secondary use for the ebike would be for longer weekend warrior trips to neighbouring Gulf Islands where I carry heavy panniers with camping gear. It would also be great to have the flexibility to take it on some easy cross-country trails (hard packed, minimal tree roots etc.).
I am trying to choose between a few different makes/models:
I am having a hard time finding the perfect bike. I like the zippiness of the Bosch Performance Line CX and Yamaha motors), but the Giant Quick E does not have suspension forks and I am wondering if that would get uncomfortable on bumpy city streets, especially since I have lower back SI joint issues. I like how quiet the Bosch Active Line Plus motor is, but I am wondering if I will get bored with how non-zippy/sporty is feels compared to the Performance Line CX or Yamaha systems.
I am also not a big fan of the Haibike styling, but that is my lowest priority—I can live with anything. I do however, prefer a bike with clean lines that doesn’t look like an ebike. For this reason, the Cube Touring and Giant Quick-E are really nice with their integrated batteries.
Also, my hard upper limit for cost is $3,000 CDN plus tax! Of course, I would be happy to pay less for a great bike. What are your thoughts on the best fit?
ReplyCourt
6 years agoHi Aimee! Sorry for the late reply here. I think you’re on the right track, and CUBE would probably be my first choice here based on quality, availability in Canada, and comfort with the suspension fork. The Giant products have been good, but Trek has been a real leader with price and range of models. I do like the Verve+ but still prefer suspension and would go for the Bosch Performance Line motor if possible because it is more fun and will probably handle light trails better. BULLS is another company that you could explore. They have a great range of products that are priced well for the quality and accessories provided.
Replybiker
6 years agoI bought Giant Quick E+2019 model a week ago. Felt like a breeze for 1st 3 days and I would do 25km a day easily & I am not a very fit person. Suddenly it has just started as pulsating – it gives me a sudden push & then breaks the power & gives a push for few seconds and backs off again. Prior to this happening the display was showing a spanner icon but it went away itself. Any suggestions what could be possibly causing this issue. It’s giving me a lot of grief.
ReplyCourt
6 years agoOh, that’s no fun! I wonder what the issue is. Definitely take it back to the dealer and ask for some help. In my experience, the Yamaha drive systems are very reliable. Before you go too much further on the system I would definitely take it in for a checkup so it doesn’t get worse. I believe that you get a two year warranty on the bike and they might just swap it out if the issue cannot be easily diagnosed. Good luck!
ReplyTom Cramer
5 years agoHello, I am considering a 2017 Giant quick e+ that was a demo at a local bike shop. It has 166 miles on it and they are asking $2200. Considering this is now a 3 year old bike, is this a good value, or should I spend that money on a later model year bike? I love your reviews and appreciate your opinion. Thanks
ReplyCourt
5 years agoHi Tom! Great question… the product used high quality equipment, but batteries age, and I’m not sure Giant sells the custom packs that would fit this frame (or how long they will support it if they do). I’d check on that, and consider the high price (often $800+) that a new battery costs. If the bike was left uncharged or the pack was cycled a lot, or it was exposed to high heat, then you’d be better off spending more upfront for a newer ebike. I hope this helps! It’s sad, because I like recycling and re-using, but some of the ebikes of past years just aren’t as easy to keep going and have proprietary batteries that aren’t easily repacked by services like this, because they have software walls and fancy circuitry that is designed to not be as open.
ReplyBlake
4 years agoBased on EBR’s review, I purchased the Giant Quick E. As a person with MS who has limited abilities to walk and bike, The Quick E has allowed me to bike again. Three weeks ago, the bike’s battery charger stopped working. I took the bike and charger to the bike shop where I purchased the bike. They said the charger is no longer on Giant’s purchase website, and Giant does not sell parts to customers directly. The bike shop believes Giant has a charger, but the bike shop and I have been e-mailing Giant for 3 weeks, and Giant has not responded. After paying $3,000 for a bike, the least Giant can do is respond to their dealers and customers. Why should I ever purchase a Giant bike again if they will not respond to help a good customer who likes their product and just needs an essential part.
ReplyCourt
4 years agoOh my gosh, that’s terrible! I am so sorry to hear this, Blake. That makes me very sad… Giant has been difficult for me to reach and review for as well (which is why I haven’t covered many of their products). I hope that their team improves customer support, because it seems like a big waste if you cannot ride your ebike anymore! I hope that your comment can serve to warn others, and that they eventually do get back to you with a solution. Perhaps it’s just the pandemic causing communication delays? I’m just so sorry… I also have a friend with MS, and I know that sucks. If you want to text me about getting a good deal on another ebike, I’ll see what I can do in terms of asking around about deals and stuff. It’s not much, but I’ll also pitch in $100 to help you out. My number is 650-930-0342 and my name is Court
Reply