One of the only fat tire style electric bikes I've tested to date that is legally capable of 25+ mph top speeds in pedal assist mode
Good value considering the custom fat frame in two sizes, solid warranty and availability, hydraulic disc brakes, 10 speed cassette and refined electronics (locking removable battery, backlit display that swivels, advanced pedal assist sensor)
Throttle mode cuts out at 6 mph if you aren't pedaling along (reached 20 mph if you are), no fender, rack or bottle cage bosses
This is the review for the 2015 E3 Sumo, in 2016 an updated model arrived with sturdy thru-axles, an optional $50 boost mode that acts like a throttle and a slightly altered paint job… it also costs a lot less! Check it out in the full review here.
The E3 Sumo is one of the only fat electric bikes I’ve tested that is capable of performing above 20 mph as a US legal “speed pedalec”. It uses an efficient mid-drive motor system by TranzX for climbing and reaching greater speeds and distances efficiently. While I do have a few basic gripes here including the lack of fender, rack and bottle cage bosses as well as the lack of a kickstand (like many fat tire bikes) and an early cutoff in throttle mode at ~6 mph, overall it’s an excellent ebike at an amazing price under $4k. If you like the fat bike style or plan to do trail, sand and snow riding then this is a capable option. The Kenda Juggernaut tires are 4 inches wide and can take 5 to 30 PSI for navigating soft or hard terrain respectively. I love that the bike is available in two frame sizes even though both are high-step, the top tube is angled slightly and the frame is relatively light weight at ~52 lbs but still sturdy thanks to the triangular “diamond” tube configuration. This ebike is made by Currie Technologies, a company that has been a leader in the US electric bike space since 1997 and offers one of the better warranties (lifetime frame, two year drive systems, one year battery) with a vast newtwork of dealers for testing before you buy.
Driving the bike is a 350 watt geared centerdrive from TranzX. It strikes a balance between the more affordable low-end middrives that rely on cadence sensors only and can feel jerky and the more expensive high-end systems with shift detection and rapid drive cutoff. I tested one of the early versions of this TranzX motor in 2013 and wasn’t entirely impressed however, two years later in 2015 (at the time of this review) I found the motor to be quieter, smoother and generally more responsive. It feels very zippy and torquey in throttle mode going from 0 to ~6 mph and is capable of hitting 20 mph if you pedal along. Basically, the throttle is meant to act as an override in lower levels of assist so you can “boost” up short hills without changing assist levels. For that application it works very well and while I’m not sure what the peak output is from TranzX centerdrives, I’d guess it’s upwards of 500 watts which is excellent when combined with a lower gear. The motor itself is small, well positioned (completely replacing the bottom bracket tubing) and fairly responsive. It turns a 38 tooth chainring that includes an aluminum bash guard on the outer edge and a plastic guide on the inner edge (to reduce drops). The control system on the Sumo is measuring your rear wheel speed, pedal cadence and pedal torque to deliver responsive motor output and it feels good but not quite as quick as the Bosch or Impulse system. It also lacks shift detection which means the sprockets and chain take a bit more abuse if you aren’t proactive in how you shift but the chain is extra strong and rust proof to help reduce abrasion.
Powering the Sumo is a 48 volt 8.7 amp hour battery pack reminiscent of other 2015 IZIP models. It’s well positioned on the downtube, keeping weight low and centered, and has some matching stickers to blend in with the frame a bit. I like that it’s designed to lock to the frame with a key for security but that it can be charged on or off (which also makes the bike lighter for transport). Many newer electric bikes run 48 volt systems because electricity is transferred more efficiently at higher voltage and the motor is also able to reach higher torque and power output. The cells inside are light weight, 18650 sized, energy dense Lithium-ion much like you’d find in an electric car. To help them perform best, I recommend storing in a cool dry environment between uses and maintaining a charge level between 20% and 80% so as not to stress the cells. While the pack itself does take up most of the space in the triangular section of the frame (thereby displacing a bottle cage mount) it’s similar to what I see on other models in this price range. The only downside in my mind is that the pack has to be switched on independently of the main display. So basically, you hold the rubber on/off button on the right side of the battery pack for a few seconds and then press the on/off button on the display panel for a second to get the bike rideable. This extra step is just annoying and can actually be confusing if you forget the extra step and then wonder why the display unit won’t come on.
Once the Sumo electric bike is actually switched on and ready to go, the display panel does a quick eight second countdown. I like how large the LCD readout is and that it’s mounted front and center just above the stem (with two plastic legs for extra strength). this display can swivel forward and back to help reduce glare if it’s sunny out but it’s not removable which means it could take more wear from the sun, rain or fellow pedestrians at bike racks. Near the left grip you’ve got a rubberized control pad with four unique buttons (up, down, display and power). There are four levels of assist in here and the throttle can be used to override any of them at full power (up to 20 mph) at any time if you’re pedaling. To hit that 28 mph top speed you’ll need to be in level four and using one of the higher gears. I found that the TranzX motor spins at a limited range of speeds but offers more power at those speeds and what this means is the lower gears will only go so fast, even in the highest drive mode. This works alright and just requires that you shift through one of the 10 speeds using the trigger shifters near the right grip. There is a zero mode where the throttle and pedal assist are inactive and to get to this you need to hold the display button for a couple of seconds while in assist level one. The display also has built in backlighting which can be activated by holding up for a couple of seconds (there is also a day/night light sensor built into the display for automatic lighting). All things considered, the display and control pad are great for a mid-level ebike like this. They are much improved over the 2014 Currie systems and offer lots of great feedback about your ride including an odometer and range estimator that automatically approximates how far you can go with the remaining battery power depending on which level of assist you’re in.
I feel that the IZIP E3 Sumo has found a sweet spot between performance and value and addressed one of the biggest hurdles that fat e-bikes face which is having enough power to actually move the large wheels through soft terrain. The TranzX drive system has improved significantly in recent years (or maybe I’ve just become more used to it) and while there’s still room for improvement, it definitely gets the job done at above average levels. I like that they went with cut out wheels to reduce weight and add a bit more cushion and that they upgraded the brakes to hydraulic but included motor inhibitors on the brake levers. The upgraded Wellgo pedals are nice and stiff but depending on your foot size the wider Wellgo MG-1 Magnesium Pedals might be worth considering, I like the locking grips and the quick release wheelset is super convenient for transport and maintenance. It’s a solid fat bike that is very capable of off-road riding.
Pros:
Capable of reaching higher top speeds with rigorous pedaling in the highest assist level, one of the only fat electric bikes I’ve tried that is a speed pedelec
Excellent weight distribution with the mid-frame battery pack and centerdrive motor, this improves balance and handling, especially on trails or in the sand and snow
Mid-drive motor leverages the 10 speed cassette for improved efficiency and range, great for moving the larger wheels and tires here
Cut-out rims reduce wheel weight which makes starting and steering easier, they also provide increased cushion because the tube is more flexible than the tires and it can stretch through the cutout holes
Throttle adds power dynamically (up to 20 mph) when pedaling, great for overcoming small hills with a little boost when using a lower level of assist, you can completely shut off pedal assist by holding the power button for a couple of seconds while the bike is on and in assist level 1
New 2015 display panel can swivel to reduce glare and is attached at two points for improved strength, also backlit for use in dark environments
Front and rear quick release wheels makes the bike easier to transport in your car (especially given the larger 26″ x 4″ tires), this also makes fixing flats easier while you’re out on the trail
Removable battery reduces overall weight of the bike when transporting on cars racks and makes charging easier if you store the frame in your garage (keep the battery at neutral temperatures and charged after each ride)
Available in two sizes for improved fit, both are “diamond” high-step frames which provides greater stiffness and strength than step-thru
Nice component upgrades including the SRAM X7 derailleur, locking grips and oversized aluminum alloy pedals
Hydraulic disc brakes operate without requiring much effort so you can keep a strong hold on the handlebars and avoid fatigue when braking, they are smooth and provide quick stopping power
Remote button pad on left bar is well sealed against water, blends in with the bar and is easy to reach while riding – intuitive menus make operating the bike while riding easy
Solid warranty from Currie Technologies, available to see and test ride at many shops across the United States and get serviced ongoing
Cons:
The throttle can only reach ~6 mph if you’re not pedaling along, it cuts out abruptly and leaves me wishing it could hit 20 mph on its own without pedaling along
No water bottle cage mounting points, you’ll have to use a Camelbak or get a saddle rail adapter to add a a cage separately, no rear rack mounts (consider a beam rack) or fender mounts and no kickstand
Display panel is not removable, when using the bike to commute to work or park in town this exposes it to more wear through weather and possible tampering
Value drive system with larger front ring and simpler control sensors than higher end systems like Bosch or Impulse, the motor doesn’t kick in or stop as quickly and it also can’t sense when you’re shifting gears
The battery pack has a rubber on/off switch as well as the main control pad so you have to press “on” two times to get the display to activate which takes a bit more energy and time than… not a huge deal, might reduce tampering
All new for 2019, the IZIP E3 Brio is an affordable and lightweight commuter with a lot of included goodies, an SR Suntour rear hub-motor, two frame styles and two color options, and an entry level price point. 7 speed Shimano derailleur, mechanical disc brakes, integrated fenders, battery integrated lights, adjustable rear rack,…...
An affordable entry level hardtail mountain mid-drive ebike that is at home on the streets and trails, priced at $1,999 and legal for all Class 1 jurisdictions. Comes in a mid-step and high-step, two different colors (black with yellow accents or blue…...
A new and unique frame for 2019 that is striking and comes in two frame sizes, each with a different wheel size, both really look great in the two colors and reflective accents available. Some key features like battery intergraded front and rear lights, a throttle, and a battery…...
All new for 2019, the IZIP E3 Simi is an affordable and lightweight cruiser with comfortable riding position and an SR Suntour rear hub motor, two frame styles and two color options, and an entry level price point. Mechanical disc brakes, paint matched steel frame, integrated lights, rear rack, comfortable riding geometry, swept…...
A value-priced hardtail electric mountain bike with basic 100mm SR Suntour spring suspension fork and knobby Vee Rubber tires, no lockout or preload adjust, no puncture protection or tubeless setup. Available in three frame sizes and two frame styles, I like the mid-step frame because…...
A relatively lightweight, approachable, comfortable cruiser electric bike, oversized saddle and padded grips dampen vibration, available in two colorways and three frame sizes to fit style preferences and body types. 26-inch wheels lower the frame height and provide more strength than 700c, high-volume 2.4-inch Schwalbe…...
An urban oriented speed pedelec, capable of 28 mph pedal-assisted speeds, complete with wide alloy fenders, a streamlined rear rack, and integrated LED lights. Powerful hydraulic disc brakes with adjustable levers, the front rotor is larger at 180mm and…...
A full suspension trail style electric bike with 130 mm travel, purpose-built frame comes in two sizes with internally routed cables, custom motor integration, sturdy Boost hub spacing. Nimble 2.6" plus sized tires balance traction, stability, and comfort with precision, control, and weight…...
A value-priced cruiser from a larger trusted company, available in a high-step and mid-step frame styles with one color pattern for each (white or metallic gray). Efficient mid-drive motor keeps weight low and center, the battery clicks in from the left…...
An efficient, feature-complete, speed pedelec capable of ~28 mph top speed with excellent frame balance but limited suspension and comfort options. Alloy fenders and minimalist rear rack stay quiet on bumpy terrain, an alloy chain guide…...
A mean looking cross country style hardtail electric mountain bike, beautifully integrated battery pack and motor keep weight low and center, has rear-rack bosses!. Locking removable battery pack can be charged on or off the bike, the display is…...
A value-priced urban electric bike that includes fenders, integrated LED lights, a rear rack, and hydraulic disc brakes, it's available in three frame sizes but only high-step. This is a high-speed Class 3 ebike that can reach ~28 mph assisted and because…...
A rigid electric fat bike with provisions for front and rear racks, available in two frame sizes for improved fit, designed with a steep top tube for comfortable stand over and steadying. Beautifully integrated Bosch Performance Line CX motor and battery pack, downtube is cut away and…...
A purpose-built electric tricycle with efficient and well-balanced middrive motor system, powerful 48 volt battery and optional second battery bay for increased range, rear wheel drive offers good traction. Comfortable swept-back handlebar with ergonomic grips, massive padded saddle with springs and hybrid tires keep…...
A value-driven full suspension electric cross country mountain bike with higher end drive system and components from Bosch, SRAM and RockShox, it's $300 cheaper than prior year with lots of upgrades. Beautiful hydroformed frame with inset battery mount and tapered head tube, the motor hangs down…...
One of the coolest looking, most feature rich high-speed electric bicycles I've tested... the battery is beautifully integrated and the small motor stays almost completely hidden behind the chainring. Pedal assist gets you 28 mph using speed, cadence and torque sensing and you can…...
One of the lighter weight, higher powered and more affordable off-road capable fat bikes I've tested, you get 15 mm and 12 mm thru-axles with quick release and punched out rims. Sturdy Shimano M396 hydraulic disc brakes front and rear, no motor inhibitors in the levers…...
A 650B hardtail trail or mountain ebike with a powerful 73 Nm mid-drive motor, it's one of the quieter motors but less responsive (mostly cadence sensing) and no shift sensing. Nice 180 mm hydraulic disc brakes, quick release for both wheels and a 15 mm…...
A feature complete speed pedelec (capable of ~28 mph top speeds) with a high torque mid-drive motor from TranzX. Quality full length plastic fenders from SKS with integrated mud flaps, mid-level suspension fork with…...
An efficient, light weight commuter electric bike available in two frame sizes and high-step or step-thru styles, the adjustable stem and swept back bars support a surprisingly comfortable upright body position. Narrower tires, firm saddle and all-Aluminum frame and fork provide great power transfer when pedaling…...
An approachable electric bike with deep low-step frame, adjustable stem, swept back handle bars and a large comfortable saddle. Simple linear pull brakes work well and are easy to adjust, quick release skewers on…...
A high powered, cruiser style electric bike with four levels of zippy pedal assist and a twist throttle drive mode. Available in two high-step sizes (18" and 20") and one step-thru (18") for easier mounting,…...
Full suspension electric bike with powerful mid-drive motor for effective climbing and balanced weight, higher ~28 mph top speed. Removable battery pack and quick release wheels make charging and servicing convient, reduce weight when…...
Hardtail trail-ready electric bike with powerful centerdrive motor for effective climbing and balanced weight, ~28 mph top speed. Removable battery pack for convenient charging and reduced transport weight, lockout suspension fork by RockShox…...
Cruiser style electric bike with two frame styles, two frame sizes, 11 custom colors and a wonderfully balanced purpose-built frame. Removable battery can be charged on or off the bike, optional matching fenders, rear rack…...
Near-silent commuter style electric bike offering pedal assist and throttle mode, fenders and a carry rack. Comfortable ride with upright seating position, swept back handlebars and oversized Velo comfort saddle...
High performance city style electric bike that offers throttle mode up to 20mph and pedal assist up to 28mph. Comfortable ride with oversized 700x45c tires, suspension fork with lockout and updated Velo Street saddle...
A sturdy, highly adjustable city bike that's perfect for rentals or fleets. High torque 400 watt direct drive motor is quiet and extremely durable, encased in rear…...
An active urban-style electric bike with near-silent motor operation and clean design helping it blend in. Strong 500 watt motor paired with large 48 volt battery that's removable and uses premium…...
Sturdy, stiff and capable of hauling cargo with the reinforced front basket and welded rear rack. Oversized tires, adjustable stem and seat post suspension improved comfort when riding...
High quality features and well rounded drive system at an excellent price. Strong but quiet 500 watt gearless rear hub motor offers throttle mode and torque-sensing pedal…...
Mid-level off road electric mountain bike with excellent weight distribution. Centerdrive motor offers high-torque, leverages rear cassette and makes servicing wheels and tires much easier...
Strong 500 watt motor is capable of moving heavier riders and heavier loads in the integrated racks. Weight is spread out from rear and kept low to the ground with battery built…...
Solid frame with oversized cushy tires and seat delivers a fluid enjoyable ride. Powerful 500 watt geared rear hub motor paired with 36 volt Lithium-ion battery offers torque…...
Ultra powerful and rugged long-range electric bike, originally designed for use by the Los Angeles police force for urban patrols. Unique mid-drive belt system delivers high torque for climbing and accelerating, speed pedelec design capable…...
Powerful 500 Watt motor paired with strong 36 Volt battery for acceleration and climbing ability. Sensitive pedal assist mode becomes jerky when climbing hills but is otherwise very responsive...
Upright seating with high-rise handlebars, wide sprung saddle and seat post shock for improved comfort. 250 watt brushless rear hub motor works well with pedal assist or throttle mode for…...
Discontinued in 2009, replaced with the E3 Path which is sturdier, less expensive and features twist throttle as well as pedal assist. Designed to be pedaled, the Trekking Enlightened lacks throttle mode but features 24 speed, lights,…...
A relaxed, comfortable and stable cruiser style electric bike with integrated downtube-battery that keeps weight low and center. Smooth torque sensing pedal assist is responsive but requires more care when working on the…...
Hi Court, I love your impartial reviews and am grateful for your mindful efforts! I have a question on the specs above: On Currie’s specs for the 2015 Sumo, they list the motor as “Currie Electro-Drive® Centerdrive,” but this review says it’s a TranzX. Is TranzX a Currie-brand motor, or did they switch at some point?
Hi Jim! Great question and thanks for your compliments. I believe the motor is made by TranzX but rebranded and presented as “Currie Electro-Drive” as part of their system which includes display, battery and motor. If you look at the images above, the second photo shows a closeup of the motor and you can see that molded into the plastic is the “TranzX” name. Currie Izip mid drive ebikes mostly all use this same motor from TranzX but now they also have one from Simano that’s part of the STEPS system on the Raleigh Misceo. Raleigh is owned by Accell Group just like IZIP.
Hey James! That sounds cool. No, unfortunately I do not have details on the Rohloff 14 speedhub but maybe a shop like Propel Bikes would. I know that Chris carries a bunch of products that come with Rohloff pre-installed. I hope this helps point you in the right direction and that he could help, or maybe someone here in the comments or the EBR forum parts section would know :)
Jim Bothwell
9 years agoHi Court, I love your impartial reviews and am grateful for your mindful efforts! I have a question on the specs above: On Currie’s specs for the 2015 Sumo, they list the motor as “Currie Electro-Drive® Centerdrive,” but this review says it’s a TranzX. Is TranzX a Currie-brand motor, or did they switch at some point?
ReplyCourt Rye
9 years agoHi Jim! Great question and thanks for your compliments. I believe the motor is made by TranzX but rebranded and presented as “Currie Electro-Drive” as part of their system which includes display, battery and motor. If you look at the images above, the second photo shows a closeup of the motor and you can see that molded into the plastic is the “TranzX” name. Currie Izip mid drive ebikes mostly all use this same motor from TranzX but now they also have one from Simano that’s part of the STEPS system on the Raleigh Misceo. Raleigh is owned by Accell Group just like IZIP.
ReplyJames Reed
5 years agoI have a 2015 Sumo and love it. I want to upgrade to a Rohloff 14 speed hub but wanted to make sure this hub is 190mm wide. Can you tell me if it is.
ReplyCourt
5 years agoHey James! That sounds cool. No, unfortunately I do not have details on the Rohloff 14 speedhub but maybe a shop like Propel Bikes would. I know that Chris carries a bunch of products that come with Rohloff pre-installed. I hope this helps point you in the right direction and that he could help, or maybe someone here in the comments or the EBR forum parts section would know :)
Reply